I submit the following "prayer" from skeptic James Randi in response to President Bush's prayer to a "loving God", regarding the massacre of 32 innocent people on the campus of Virginia Tech. This response can be found at Randi's own website, dedicated to exposing fraud and foolishness.
I agree with every word Mr. Randi has written.
To God the Father Almighty, Creator of Heaven and Earth, God of Abraham, Jehovah, whoever or whatever:
God, You in Your omniscience – You know everything, past present and future – and also in Your omnipotence – You can do anything You want to do – why, 23 years ago, did You create this deluded man Seung-Hui Cho, then allow him to buy the guns, go to the Virginia Tech campus, and slaughter all those students and faculty? That took long-term planning, determined intention, and careful nurturing of Cho’s delusions and hatred, by You. God, what’s “loving” about that? Our President may labor under the delusion that such an act somehow shows Your “loving” nature, but in my admitted ignorance, I cannot see that. Help me to understand.
Or was this – forgive my suggestion, God – yet another failure of Your Intelligent Design, along with tobacco, cancer, spina bifida, and Crohn’s Disease?
A better plan, God – in my humble opinion – would have been to prevent that horrendous, senseless, slaughter, and then You would have had no reason to have to “comfort” those parents, friends, fellow-students and so many others who will now have to do without the delight of knowing these beautiful people. You see, God, You could have saved the lives – and futures – not only of those 32, but of Mr. Cho, as well! This deranged young man, angry and desperate, reacted to a society he felt was opposing him. He murdered 32 persons because he felt he had to, in answer to impulses he could not control. But You, Almighty God, Creator of Heaven and Earth, etc., etc., could have intervened – “omnipotent,” remember? – and there would be far less sorrow in our nation today.
Why did You do this to us? The figures show us that most of us believe in You, believe in Your loving nature, and appeal to You for Your comfort even after You have decided to allow tragedies such as this to happen; doesn’t that count? Personally, I don’t believe in You, but don’t the numbers count?
God, I’m sure that Dr. Richard Roberts, president of Oral Roberts University, speaks for You when he says, “…there’s no doubt that this act was Satanic in origin." He calls Cho's recently-revealed writings, “just words,” which he says are “one of Satan’s tools to bring about Man’s destruction.” Now, this fits the Christian idea of demonic possession, which says that human existence is predicated on the narrative of Man’s Fall from Grace in the Garden of Eden, and that wherever there is good, Satan is trying to destroy it.
Please, God, try to get Your act together, or there may be fewer people out there willing to appease a jealous, callous, vindictive, cruel, obviously insecure deity such as Yourself. And what would You do then?
God only knows…
You know, I'm so sick of this trope that "atheists are nowhere to be found" when there's a tragedy like this. Bullshit. I'm not an atheist (although my own spiritual practices are hardly mainstream), but in my experience, the more secular a person is, the more likely s/he is to pitch in and provide real help at a time like this - as opposed to the Pharisaical posturing of the "devout" who all want you to know how devout they are but can't be bothered to get their hands (or their wallets) dirty with a little real aid to those who most need it.
ReplyDeletelilith,
ReplyDeleteCampus groups like InterVarsity Christian Fellowship and Chi Alpha Ministries were involved with counseling students at VT. In addition, the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association sent 20 chaplains trained in crisis counseling. I'm not surprised you weren't aware of this; the mainstream media didn't report this very much (if at all).
Regarding the "devout" that "can't be bothered to get their hands (or their wallets) dirty with a little real aid to those who most need it": In December 2005 I provided this response to the question If I only had contemporary Christianity as it currently presents itself in the public sphere to look at-- what on Earth would there be to recommend it as the peaceful, loving belief system it claims to be?
(Forgive me if it sounds like bragging, but I just wanted to set the record straight.)
jobsanger,
ReplyDeleteI plan on posting a response to Mr. Randi's "prayer," but it might take me awhile to finish, so please be patient.
Oh, jobsanger, now you done it. By posting this, you've condemned your eternal soul to Hell.
ReplyDeleteNote: "Hell" in this comment is defined as "having endless comments by Curious Texan posted to your blog"
:)
Interesting to know.
ReplyDelete