Showing posts with label Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Show all posts

Monday, September 28, 2020

Barrett On The Court Will Undo Decades Of Progress

In 1991, President George H.W. Bush nominated Clarence Thomas to replace Thurgood Marshall on the Supreme Court. He thought nominating a Black man to replace a Black man on the court would placate Americans. He was wrong.

Thurgood Marshall was a giant, who had fought to increase the rights of American citizens his entire life. Clarence Thomas had tried to curb those same rights in his time on the court. While both men were Black, Clarence Thomas has never been, and never will be, the equal of Thurgood Marshall.

Now history seems to be repeating itself. Donald Trump says he is replacing one of the great female justices to ever serve on the Supreme Court with a woman. He seems to think that will placate the public. He is wrong. Justice Ginsburg, like Thurgood Marshall, was a warrior for citizen rights throughout her life. Amy Coney Barrett, if her past is to be believed, will work to undo all the accomplishments of Ginsburg. She will destroy decades of progress.

Here's just part of the excellent op-ed by Lara Bazelon in The New York Times on this subject:

President Trump’s promise to name a woman to replace Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who died on Sept. 18 at 87, was cynical and insulting to the millions of women who view the late Supreme Court justice as a feminist icon. Senator John Barrasso, a Wyoming Republican, praised the decision as a “powerful positive statement” to young women, who would embrace the president’s nominee as a “role model.” The message to women is clear: Nothing to see here, ladies! One of you is as good as any other.

But Mr. Trump’s pick, Amy Coney Barrett, is no Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

Women aren’t gym socks, purchased in bulk so that a replacement can be seamlessly substituted into the rotation when one goes missing in the washing machine. The next Supreme Court justice will cast crucial votes that affect women’s fundamental rights, including the right to control their own bodies and to gain access to affordable health care for themselves and their families. The fact that President Trump’s nominee is a woman matters less if she does not support the causes at the heart of the long, continuing march for gender equality that Justice Ginsburg championed. . . .

Judge Barrett, who is on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, has impeccable intellectual credentials — and a record that stands in stark contrast to Justice Ginsburg’s. She has written that abortion is “always immoral,” and joined two dissents against decisions supporting the right to choose. One decision stopped the enforcement of a state law that would have required a minor — regardless of her maturity or family situation — to notify her parents of her decision to have an abortion, giving them veto power, unless a judge found this was not in her best interests.

The other decision struck down a state law banning abortions at any stage of pregnancy based on fetal disabilities, including those that were life-threatening. (The law also banned abortions based on race, ethnicity and gender.) Judge Barrett dissented from a ruling banning people with felony convictions from possessing firearms, and publicly criticized Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. for voting with the high court’s liberal bloc to uphold the Affordable Care Act, saying he pushed the statute “beyond its plausible meaning” to save it.

Make no mistake: Judge Barrett’s confirmation will be the wrecking ball that finally smashes Roe v. Wade and undoes the Affordable Care Act. Her crucial vote on these cases and so many others will undo decades of the progress that Justice Ginsburg worked her whole life to achieve. . . .

Republicans would have us believe that ramming through Justice Ginsburg’s replacement less than two months before the election — and after denying President Obama, who had 11 months left in his second term, the chance to replace Justice Antonin Scalia — is fine and dandy because, well, the new justice is a woman. . . .

On her deathbed, Justice Ginsburg wrote that her “most fervent wish” was that a new justice would not be installed until after the election. It is a cold calculation by the president, a master misogynist, that the nomination of a woman, in and of itself, would be enough to soften any opposition to the ugliness of a rushed, hypocritical and nakedly political charade. Think again Mr. President: We aren’t stupid.

Sunday, September 27, 2020

Ginsburg Was Motivated By Principle - McConnell By Power

 

The following post is by former Labor Secretary Robert Reich on his blog. Once again, he hits the nail right on its head!

People in public life tend to fall into one of two broad categories – those who are motivated by principle, and those motivated by power. 

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who died Friday night at the age of 87, exemplified the first. 

When he nominated her in 1993, Bill Clinton called her “the Thurgood Marshall of gender-equality law,” comparing her advocacy and lower-court rulings in pursuit of equal rights for women with the work of the great jurist who advanced the cause of equal rights for Black people. Ginsburg persuaded the Supreme Court that the 14th Amendment’s guarantee of equal protection applied not only to racial discrimination but to sex discrimination as well.

For Ginsburg, principle was everything – not only equal rights, but also the integrity of democracy. Always concerned about the consequences of her actions for the system as a whole, she advised young people “to fight for the things you care about but do it in a way that will lead others to join you.”

Mitch McConnell, the Senate majority leader, exemplifies the second category. He couldn’t care less about principle. He is motivated entirely by the pursuit of power.

McConnell refused to allow the Senate to vote on President Barack Obama’s nominee to the Supreme Court, Merrick Garland, in March, 2016 – almost a year before the end of Obama’s term of office – on the dubious grounds that the “vacancy should not be filled until we have a new president.” 

McConnell’s move was a pure power grab. No Senate leader had ever before asserted the right to block a vote on a president’s nominee to the Supreme Court. 

McConnell’s “principle” of waiting for a new president disappeared Friday evening, after Ginsburg’s death was announced.

Just weeks before one of the most consequential presidential elections in American history, when absentee voting has already begun in many states (and will start in McConnell’s own state of Kentucky in 25 days), McConnell announced: “President Trump’s nominee will receive a vote on the floor of the United States Senate.” 

This is, after all, the same Mitch McConnell who, soon after Trump was elected, ended the age-old requirement that Supreme Court nominees receive 60 votes to end debate and allow for a confirmation vote, and then, days later, pushed through Trump’s first nominee, Neil Gorsuch.

Ginsburg and McConnell represent the opposite poles of public service today. The distinction doesn’t depend on whether someone is a jurist or legislator – I’ve known many lawmakers who cared more about principle than power, such as the late congressman John Lewis. It depends on values. 

Ginsburg refused to play power politics. As she passed her 80th birthday, near the start of Obama’s second term, she dismissed calls for her to retire in order to give Obama plenty of time to name her replacement, saying she planned to stay “as long as I can do the job full steam,” adding “There will be a president after this one, and I’m hopeful that that president will be a fine president.”

She hoped others would also live by principle, including McConnell and Trump. Just days before her death she said, “My most fervent wish is that I will not be replaced until a new president is installed.” 

Her wish will not be honored. 

If McConnell cannot muster the senate votes needed to confirm Trump’s nominee before the election, he’ll probably try to fill the vacancy in the lame-duck session after the election. He’s that shameless. 

Not even with Joe Biden president and control over both the House and Senate can Democrats do anything about this – except by playing power politics themselves: expanding the size of the court or restructuring it so justices on any given case are drawn from a pool of appellate judges.

The deeper question is which will prevail in public life: McConnell’s power politics or Ginsburg’s dedication to principle? 

The problem for America, as for many other democracies at this point in history, is this is not an even match. Those who fight for power will bend or break rules to give themselves every advantage. Those who fight for principle are at an inherent disadvantage because bending or breaking rules undermines the very ideals they seek to uphold. 

Over time, the unbridled pursuit of power wears down democratic institutions, erodes public trust, and breeds the sort of cynicism that invites despotism. 

The only bulwark is a public that holds power accountable – demanding stronger guardrails against its abuses and voting power-mongers out of office. 

Ruth Bader Ginsburg often referred to Justice Louis Brandeis’s famous quote, that “the greatest menace to freedom is an inert people.” Indeed.

Saturday, September 19, 2020

Defender Of Justice, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Has Died

 

America has suffered a great tragedy. At the age of 87, Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg has died.

She will always be remembered for her fight for equal rights for all Americans and her strong belief in justice for all.

She had been ill for a while now, but had held on to her position on the court to prevent Donald Trump from appointing her replacement. Sadly her failing health would not let her complete that mission.

She will be sorely missed, and will go down in history as one of our greatest Supreme Court Justices.

There is no doubt that Trump will try to appoint a replacement, and Mitch McConnell has said he would try to push any Trump nomination through the Senate -- in spite of the fact that he refused to even consider an Obama nomination four years ago with only months left in his term.

The Republicans have enough senators in this Congress to approve a Trump nominee if they want. Our only hope is that a few senators, struggling to get re-elected, will vote to stop the nomination (of a Kavanaugh-like candidate). Any nomination is going to be controversial, and the Senate might not want to take action close to the election. But there will be two months after the election in which to act -- and they probably will.

This will likely insure a right-wing and corporate-friendly court for many years to come.

Sunday, August 25, 2019

Democrats Get A Scare Regarding Ruth Bader Ginsburg

The last thing this country needs is another Supreme Court justice appointed by Donald Trump. Democrats across the country are hoping the next few justices will be appointed by a New Democratic president.

But a news story on Friday put that in doubt in the minds of many Democrats. It was reported that Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg recently received treatment for a cancer on her pancreas.

Here's how NPR reported it:

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg has just completed three weeks of radiation treatment at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center in New York, the U.S. Supreme Court disclosed Friday.
The radiation therapy, conducted on an outpatient basis, began Aug. 5, shortly after a localized cancerous tumor was discovered on Ginsburg's pancreas. The treatment included the insertion of a stent in Ginsburg's bile duct, according to a statement issued by the court.
Doctors at Sloan Kettering said further tests showed no evidence of disease elsewhere in the body. The treatment comes just months after Ginsburg was operated on for lung cancer last December. The 86-year-old justice has been treated for cancer in various forms over the past 20 years.
"Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg today completed a three-week course of stereotactic ablative radiation therapy at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center in New York City," a statement from the Supreme Court read. "The focused radiation treatment began on August 5 and was administered on an outpatient basis to treat a tumor on her pancreas. The abnormality was first detected after a routine blood test in early July, and a biopsy performed on July 31 at Sloan Kettering confirmed a localized malignant tumor.
"As part of her treatment, a bile duct stent was placed. The Justice tolerated treatment well. She cancelled her annual summer visit to Santa Fe, but has otherwise maintained an active schedule. The tumor was treated definitively and there is no evidence of disease elsewhere in the body. Justice Ginsburg will continue to have periodic blood tests and scans. No further treatment is needed at this time.". . .
During Ginsburg's three weeks of treatment in New York, she kept up a busy schedule in New York, often going out in the evening to the movies, the opera and the theater. . . .
The justice also continued to work during her time in New York, according to court sources, and she has been spotted frequently window shopping, even going in to try on shoes and other items that have interested her.
Ginsburg has 11 public events planned for September and has not canceled any of them to date.
The Supreme Court is set to open a new term on the first Monday in October, and the justices routinely return to work in September.

Tuesday, April 05, 2016

Supreme Court Unanimously Upholds Equal Representation


The U.S. Supreme Court just issued an important decision -- and that decision was a huge victory for equal representation in the United States.

The case had been brought forward by some Texas right-wingers. They said that states should not have to divide house and senate districts by total population, but could divide those districts by registered voters, or by actual voters. They wanted to do that kind of division because it would allow them to draw more districts favorable to Republicans.

But the Supreme Court was unified in its opposition to this idea -- voting 8 to 0 to support the division as it is now (on the number of residents, and not the number of voters). The court said that all residents, including non-voters, deserve equal representation -- and that means the districts should have a roughly equal number of residents.

The court's opinion was written by Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. She wrote:

“Appellants have shown no reason for the Court to disturb this longstanding use of total population.” 

“Adopting voter-eligible apportionment as constitutional command would upset a well-functioning approach to districting that all 50 states and countless local jurisdictions have followed for decades, even centuries.”

“. . .representatives serve all residents, not just those eligible or registered to vote.”

“Nonvoters have an important stake in many policy debates—children, their parents, even their grandparents, for example, have a stake in a strong public-education system—and in receiving constituent services, such as help navigating public-benefits bureaucracies. By ensuring that each representative is subject to requests and suggestions from the same number of constituents, total population apportionment promotes equitable and effective representation.”

Thursday, February 19, 2015

Ruth Bader Ginsburg

Ruth Bader Ginsburg has become my favorite justice on the current United States Supreme Court. She may be small of stature, but she has a huge heart, a giant spirit, and an indomitable will -- and she is never afraid to speak out for those who need help, or whose rights are being violated. I think she'll be remembered as one of our greatest justices.

Here are a few quotes from her in a recent MSNBC interview:

ON ABORTION:

“We will never see a day when women of means are not able to get a safe abortion in this country.”

“All the restrictions, they operate against the woman who doesn’t have freedom to move, to go where she is able to get safely what she wants.”


“I don’t want to make any predictions. But precedent is important in this court.” (Overturning Roe) “could happen, but I think it’s not a likely scenario.”

ON RACIAL OPPRESSION:

“Throwing out preclearance when it has worked and is continuing to work to stop discriminatory changes is like throwing away your umbrella in a rainstorm because you are not getting wet.”

“People who think you could wave a magic wand and the legacy of the past will be over are blind.”

“We’ve come a long way from the days where there was state enforced segregation. But we still have a way to go.”

ON CONGRESS:

“The current Congress is not equipped really to do anything. The kind of result that we got in the Ledbetter case is not easily achieved today. Someday, we will go back to having the kind of legislature that we should, where members, whatever party they belong to, want to make the thing work and cooperate with each other to see that that will happen.” 

ON HERSELF:

“My aspirations have not changed since the ’70s. . . .my hope for our society that we’re going to use the talent of all of the people and not just half of them. I would contrast an earlier period in my life, when I just accepted discrimination as that’s the way things are, nothing I can do about it.”

“I try to teach through my opinions, through my speeches – how wrong it is to judge people on the basis of what they look like, [the] color of their skin, whether they’re men or women.”

ON HOW SHE'D LIKE TO BE REMEMBERED:

“Someone who used whatever talent she had to do her work to the very best of her ability. And to help repair tears in her society, to make things a little better through the use of whatever ability she has.”

(The caricature of Justice Ginsburg above is by DonkeyHotey.)