Showing posts with label Lincoln Chafee. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Lincoln Chafee. Show all posts

Thursday, October 15, 2015

The "Oops" Moment In The Democratic Debate

Yesterday I remarked that the minor Democratic candidates had performed fairly well in the debate, but not well enough to make any of them a contender. After sleeping for a night on that, I now think I must revise that. While that is true of O'Malley and Webb, it is not true for Lincoln Chafee (pictured).

Chafee had a Rick Perry-style "oops" moment in the debate, and like Perry, it is likely to kill his candidacy. The moment came when Anderson Cooper asked Chafee about his vote to repeal the Glass-Steagall Act. Chafee, looking like a deer caught in the headlights, clearly shot himself in the foot with his answer.

Here is how WPRI.com describes that exchange:

Pressed by moderator Anderson Cooper of CNN about his 1999 vote to repeal the Depression-era Glass-Steagall Act that regulated large financial institutions – a change often cited on the left as a key contributor to the financial crisis – Chafee gave the verbal equivalent of a shrug, saying the vote came just two days after Gov. Lincoln Almond appointed him to finish the unexpired Senate term of his father, John Chafee, who had died the month before.


“Glass-Steagall was my very first vote – I had just arrived; my dad had died in office, I was appointed to the office – it was my first vote,” Chafee said.
“Are you saying you didn’t know what you voted for?” Cooper asked.
“I’d just arrived in the Senate,” Chafee replied. “I think we get some takeovers, and that was one of my very first votes, and it was 90 to 5.”
“With all due respect, senator,” Cooper said, “what does that say about you – that you were casting a vote for something you weren’t really sure about?”
“I think you’re being a little rough,” Chafee replied. “I had just arrived at the United States Senate. I’d been mayor of my city – my dad had died, I’d been appointed by the governor, it was my first vote, and it was 90 to 5 because it was a conference report.”
That was a terrible answer to Cooper's valid question. Democrats liked the Glass-Steagal Act, and they would like to see it passed again. It was this act that prevented the giant financial institutions from playing the stock market with money belonging to their customers, and its repeal was one of the major reasons for the crash in 2007-2008 that caused the Great Recession.

This was not a "gotcha" question. And if Chafee had been smart enough, he could easily have deflected it. All he had to do was say something like -- "I made a mistake. I know better now, and if given the chance, I will fight to re-instate the Glass-Steagall Act". Democrats are a forgiving bunch, and probably would have accepted an answer like that.

But he didn't say that. Instead he tried to make excuses -- and rather pathetic excuses at that. Then tried to shift the blame to the moderator for asking him a tough question. Well, tough questions were asked of all the candidates, and the others handled them with intelligence and grace. Chafee did not.

I'm not saying this will hurt Chafee's campaign. He was only polling between 0% and 1%, and it's had to get less than that. I am saying though that this egregious gaffe should mark the end of his rather lackluster campaign. He has shown himself to be the weakest of the Democratic candidates, and it's time for him to quit the race. He's just wasting time -- his and everyone else's.

Wednesday, October 14, 2015

My Thoughts On The Democratic Debate

(This caricature of the Democratic Debaters is by DonkeyHotey.)

I have to start by saying how disappointed I am with CNN. They would like for us to think they are just doing us all a favor by holding this debate, but it became quite obvious from the beginning that for them this was just an opportunity to make a lot of money from advertisements. The debate was scheduled for 7:30pm, but it was about 18 minutes later before the candidates actually began to speak.

I probably should have expected that, but it's still disappointing. Also disappointing was their overuse of graphics to try and turn the event into some kind of entertainment show -- rather than just an opportunity to perform their function to inform the public. But that is what corporations do -- try to make everything an entertaining and profitable venture (even when it would be better not to do that).

I will give credit to Anderson Cooper, who moderated the debate. He wasn't afraid to ask the hard questions of all the debaters -- and he did a fairly good job of making them answer those questions.

How did the candidates do in the debate? All of them did fairly well. Sanders was strong on the economic issues (which is his forte), but seemed to struggle on gun violence and the Middle East questions. Clinton was strong on gun violence, held her own on the economic issues, and sounded like the voice of reason on the Middle East. Both did well on education, opportunity, and college costs. Both did well in discussing global climate change. Both were also good on Social Security and blasted GOP attempts to cut it. Sanders wants to expand benefits, and Clinton called for enhancing benefits for those getting the smallest benefits. Both disappointed me when talking about Edward Snowden and his actions.

Sanders did have the political courage to say he would vote for marijuana legalization. I applaud him for that. Clinton was not willing to go that far (sadly), but only came out in favor of medical marijuana and decriminalizing possession. I doubt this is going to be a huge issue in the Democratic primaries though.

In the final analysis, I don't think either of them lost or gained support -- and I'm betting the polls next week look very much like the polls last week.

As for the other three, they showed (at least to me) why they are not first-tier candidates. They seemed to be struggling to stay up with Clinton and Sanders throughout the debate. I would be very surprised if any of the three start climbing much in the polls. I do think Martin O'Malley trumped all the other four with his plan to have the country 100% on green energy by 2050 -- but I doubt that will be enough to vault him into contention.

Was there a winner? Not really. Clinton and Sanders performed as expected, and neither made any real gaffes. I think the supporters of both probably left feeling satisfied with the performance of their candidate.

There are five more of these debates that will be held. After watching this one, I think that will be plenty -- and I can't agree with those who are calling for more that that.

NOTE -- One thing did sort of surprise me. I had expected a lot of talk about how bad the Republicans and their policies are, but while a few jabs were thrown, there wasn't a lot of that. For the most part, the debate was centered on Democratic issues.

Tuesday, October 13, 2015

Clinton Enters Democratic Debate With A Large Lead


Tonight, five of the six Democratic candidates for president will participate in their first debate (Lessig was not invited by CNN to participate). And Hillary Clinton enters that debate with a large lead over all of her opponents. According to the latest national poll, Clinton leads her closest competitor, Bernie Sanders, by about 19 points. That's with Joe Biden being considered a candidate. If you take Biden out of the mix, then Clinton's lead over Sanders grows to 24 points.

Will Biden be a candidate? He's still toying with the idea, but has not jumped in yet (and will not participate in the debate). I think he's waiting to see if either Clinton or Sanders commits an egregious error in tonight's debate. If they do commit an error that hurts their candidacy, then he might enter the race. If they don't, I think he'll stay out of the race.

And the way I see it -- neither Clinton nor Sanders is likely to commit an error. Sanders supporters are counting on their candidate to win the debate big, and et his campaign moving again (after being stuck in the mid-twenties for quite a while now). I doubt that will happen either. Clinton is an experienced debater. I expect both Clinton and Sanders to do a good job in the debate -- and both to remain about where they currently are in the polls after the debate.

CNN has been talking for a couple of days now about how big an opportunity this is for the minor candidates (O'Malley, Webb, Chafee) to jumpstart their own campaigns. Again, I disagree. I'm sure they will probably come out swinging in the debate, but I doubt it'll do them much good. This primary election is between Sanders and Clinton (and perhaps Biden if he enters the race). Everyone else is just wasting their time and money.

These charts were made from the results of a new CBS News Poll -- done between October 4th and 8th of a random national sample of 343 Democratic primary voters, and has a margin of error of 6 points.


-----------------------------------------------

And below is the last pre-debate net favorability rating among Democrats for Clinton and Sanders. The net favorability rating is favorability minus unfavorability (and the higher the number the better).
Note that Democrats rate Clinton's net favorability 13 points higher than Sanders'. Clinton also has a significant margin among women, Blacks, Hispanics, moderates, conservatives, 30 to 49 year-olds, 50 to 64 year-olds, and those 65 & older.

Sanders has an advantage among Whites and those 18 to 29 years-old.

Men and liberals view both candidates with an equal net favorability.

This is from a new Gallup Poll -- done between September 12th and October 10th, and has a margin of error of about 4 points.


Why Won't CNN Allow ALL Of The Candidates To Debate ?

If you've been following the political process recently, you may have noticed that while their are six Democratic candidates, only five have been invited to participate in tonight's Democratic Party presidential debate.

CNN has invited Hillary Clinton, Bernie Sanders, Martin O'Malley, Jim Webb, and Lincoln Chafee to debate the issues important to Democrats -- but Harvard Law Professor, and legitimate presidential candidate, Lawrence Lessig was not invited.

Why wasn't he invited? CNN will tell you its because he does very poorly in the polls. So what? O'Malley, Webb, and Chafee also do very poorly in the polls (sometimes failing to get even 1%), and yet they were invited. And Lessig has raised a million dollars for his campaign -- significantly more than either Webb or Chafee.

I can understand why CNN (and Fox) limited the number of candidates on the big stage for the Republican debate. Putting all 17 on the stage at the same time would have made the debate too ridiculous -- giving no candidate enough time to explain his position. They limited the number to 10 (11 in the CNN debate), but made up for it by holding a second debate for those left out of the big debate.

But that's not happening here. There are only six Democratic candidates, and there's no justifiable reason for leaving out any of the six. If CNN could handle 11 Republican candidates on the stage, then they certainly should be able to handle six Democrats debating. That is just fair (especially since there is not a second debate being held).

Evidently fairness is not important to CNN. Instead, they see themselves as some kind of gatekeeper, whose duty is to tell the American public who is a serious candidate and who is not. And in doing that, they have abandoned their own mission and subverted the job of the party members. It is up to Democrats to decide who is a viable candidate -- not CNN. It is CNN's job just to provide the information voters need to make an informed vote -- and leaving a candidate out of the debate is failing to do that job.

There's no other way to say it -- CNN was wrong to not invite Professor Lessig to debate.

(The caricature of Lawrence Lessig above is by DonkeyHotey.)